What changed now that AI answers absorb a third of commercial research — and the six questions that separate agencies who adapted from agencies who renamed a service page.
Every agency now claims AI expertise. Almost none can describe how they measure it. This guide gives you six questions you can ask in a single call, the answers that indicate real capability, and the answers that indicate a repositioned deck. We've included where we're the wrong choice too.
Every agency says they do AI search. Ask them to name the prompt set they track and the cadence they track it on — the room goes quiet fast.
— Arise GEO, Digital Marketing Agencies 2026
A digital marketing agency that can't tie a channel to revenue will always report on the metric it can control.
— Arise GEO, Digital Marketing Agencies 2026
The best question in an agency pitch is not 'what would you do for us'. It is 'describe the client you lost and why'.
— Arise GEO, Digital Marketing Agencies 2026
A credible answer names the surfaces tracked, a stable prompt set, a measurement cadence and what they do when a citation is lost. A vague answer about 'optimizing for AI' means no method exists.
Percentage-of-spend rewards budget inflation. Flat retainers align incentives. Also ask what sits outside scope: creative production, dev hours, tooling and translation are the usual surprise invoices.
Recommendations are cheap. Ask for a real ticket with acceptance criteria and effort estimates, and ask what they do when a client's developers stall for a quarter.
In most agencies these are separate pods with separate reports, double-counting the same conversion. Ask to see one roadmap covering both and one reconciled measurement model.
That update targeted bulk AI-generated content and careless programmatic SEO. An agency still selling 40 posts a month is selling you a manual-action risk.
We fit companies past $2M revenue with technical debt, real implementation capacity and an interest in the answer layer. We're wrong for pre-PMF startups, brand-only briefs, hours-based outsourcing and bulk content mandates.
We can promise this because our methodology already works. Hundreds of pages now sit in position #1 across our clients' catalogs. The risk shouldn't be on you — it's on us.
Serious multi-channel programs generally start around $6,500 a month, with senior-led work running to roughly $15,000. One-off forensic audits sit in the $4,000–$15,000 range. Anything under about $3,000 a month is usually a junior executing a template.
Specialists win when the problem is diagnosable and deep — technical SEO, a failing ad account, an AI visibility gap. Full-service wins when you need one accountable partner across channels and can accept slightly less depth in each. The worst outcome is a full-service agency that is actually four juniors.
Three months for leading indicators, six for revenue. Agree the leading indicators in writing before signing, otherwise month four becomes an argument about what was promised.
In-house wins for ongoing execution volume and institutional knowledge. Agencies win for diagnosis, senior judgement and channel breadth you can't justify hiring. Many of our clients run both: we diagnose and prioritize, their team ships.
Our alternatives hub covers twenty named competitors with honest fit notes, plus migration guides if you're switching.
Audits scoped within 24 hours. Results within 90 days, or your money back.
Request Your Audit →